Monday, 18 April 2011

Andrew Walls on the spread of Christianity

Christian history has been one of successive prenetration of diverse culture. Islamic expansion is progressive; Christian expansion is serial.

p30

... cross-cultural diffusion has been necessary to Christianity. It has been it's lifebloo, and without it the faith could not have survived.


The process of cross-cultural diffusion thus initiates means that since the first century, the church has in principle been not only multiracial, bit alsp multicultural.

p67


Christian history is the story of successive transformations of the transformation of the Christian faith following its translation into a series of diverse cultural settings.

p194

Andrew Walls 'The cross cultural process in Christian History'

Thursday, 14 April 2011

Religion in Birmingham

The history of Birmingham

from 17th century Birm developed around it's production of metal goods. By 1860 Birm and the Black country were the centre of the uk hardware production
The provision of finance and trading servces grew. Manufacturers' associations developed as markets expanded. By 1849, of the 8 leading banks in the City, 6 were Birmingham owned and managed.

Birmingham' s industrial base chaneged when the Blackcountryy's reserves of coal, limestone and iron became depleted. New processes meant that steel replaced iron leading to the decline in the old iron hardware trades in the last decades of the 19th century ...

By 1914 Birmingham's growth industries were light and medium engineering, particularly the manufacture of cycles, motor vehicles (led by Herbert Austin) and to a lesser degree electrical equipment.

Rapid Industiral expansion meant increasing population. The 71,000 resident of the city in 1801 had grwon to 401,000 by 1881 abd just over 1 million by 1931. In the 19th century people moved to the city from surrounding rural and urban areas and the was a large influx of Irish immigrants in the mid 19th century.

After 1918 Birmingham manufacture increasingly concentrated on the moror industry and associated com[ponents.

In the 1920s and 30s saw significant growth in many Birmingham industries ... so escaped the worst of the recession.

The second world war provided a significant boost to the Birmingham economy ... (but) became heavily reliant on a few growth industries of the 1930s.



(p7 - 14 FITCOB)

From Faith in the City of Birmingham, Jigsaw Cities, Migrants to the Metropolis

Conservative Evangelicalism in Birmingham

When reading the biographies and history of evangelicalism in UK there is generally very little mention of Birmingham, aside from the ministry of John Angell James.

David Bebbington in 'the dominance of evangelicalism' p126 notes that 'from 1805 down to his death in 1859 the minister was John Angell James, one of the most effective evangelistic preachers of his day; from 1853 he had a junior assistant RW Dale who took over as minister on James's death, reamining at Carr's lane until his own death in 1895. James rarely preached on the distinctive points of the Reformed scheme of thought, yet nevertheless counted himself their adherant. 'I hold', he once told Dale, 'the doctrines of Calvinism with a firm grasp!' Dale by contrast, quietly broke with Calvinism soon afer enetering the ministry.'

He also attacked PSA in 1875 and promoted the 'civic gospel' - a forerunner of the social gospel.

At the time of James there were other evangelicals, RW Dale's son in his biography of his father, notes that the clergy in the city were largley evangelical, Including Canon JC Miller at St Martins in the Bullring from 1846 - 1866. Tragicly over the next 100 years little of this heritage remained.

A side point relevant here is that in the 1800s anglicanism was comparitively weaker in Birm, as it was in other newly industrialised areas

Geoff Robson in his 'Dark Datanic Mills' p93 makes the interesting point about the decline of non conformity in the West Midlands 'During the 1830s and 1840s important social groups within the Evangelical Nonconformist constituency were not merely becoming less receptive to Nonconformist recruitment, they were becoming extinct.'

Therefore the decline in evangelicalism in 19th century Birmingham, was not just due to a hostile social climate and changing conditions, but also it's 'overwededness' to a particular social group which was in decline in the area. Something I shall return to later.

After James, when it comes to Conservative Evangelicalism - the best we have is that JI Packer was at St Johns Harborne from 1952 - 4, and when he left he doesn't seem to have looked back. Although St Johns has remained evangelical to this day.

From what I can gather (and this appears a fairly unresearched area), evangelicalism in Birmingham for the majority of the 20th century was carried by the Brethren movement. Certainly when you look at the list of churches associated with the FIEC as well as others independant evangelical churches most appear to have some heritage with the Brethren. The great tragedy as with much of the Brethren England wide is that they too are in serious decline.

The last 25 years though have seen encouraging signs in the shape of new churches which have espoused conservative evangelicalism. The first of these was South Birmingham Evangelical (now Monyhull Church)which constituted in 1989 and then City Church in 1999, which has subsequently planted Grace Church Stirchley in ....

iN 1996 Chruch Central was planted by New Frontiers and 2 years later, they planted the Crown in Handsworth

Additionally St John and St Stephens have evangelical ministers.

Whilst this is encouraging as I have said in my thesis, the growth in each of these churches is from a similar socio economic and cultural group, and has coincided with the expansion of higher education. Whilst there may be some differences in location and worship, a similar sort of people attend all of these churches, and where there are differences in colour and nationality, in culture and class there is generally little difference.

This is of concern when this group generally does not stay in the city and certainly outside a few areas in the West, North and South of the city, are fairly absent from the most populated inner areas. And with the current trajectories of population, are even declining in the areas where they are now.

These churches have had a very limited impact on the large number of first generation immigrants who have come from, 1948 onwards and have not come to Birmingham to go university (the vast majority) and their children and grandchildren. It is these people who are the future of Birmingham.

Conservative Evangelicalism in the UK - a brief history

Whilst there are clear discontinuities (with regard to activism, ecclesiology, a concern for doctrinal precision) there are also obvious continuites between elements of Puritainism and Conservative Evangelicalism (conversionism, biblicism, cruicentricism and our three Conservative Evangelical distinctives of a conservative view of the Bible, penal substitution and calvinistic soteriology)

These are also present in the ministries of George Whitfield and John Wesley (aside from the calvinistic soteriology) and the 18th century and all are present in ministries of CH Spurgeon and JC Ryle, to pick two representatives from the 19th Century, as well as EJ Poole O'Connor who bridged the 19th and 20th centuries and founded the FIEC.

As has been widely recorded evangelicalism as a whole declined at the end of the 19th century, under attack from naturalism (in the shape of evolution), higher criticism and the Oxford Movement, as well as sociatal changes - the growth of leisure.

However after the second world war, God raised a number of gifted leaders (Lloyd Jones, Stott and Packer, who along with Douglas Johnson the founder of IVF,

One key element which is generally not highlighted in the various histories and biographies of conservative evangelicalism in the 20th century is the middle / upper middle class nature of the movement. I would argue that the emphasis put on student ministry both in terms of

Aside from Lloyed Jones (in his first pastorate at Sandfields) - none of the big 3 were ever involved in ministry outide the university educated.

Whilst they may have not meant to exlcude, the effect of this has been

If you were to attend any of the larger scale meetings which characterise CE in 2011, new word alive, the men's conventions, and the gosepl partneship meetings and ask who has had some involvement with UCCF at some point, I would suspect most hands would go up,

If you were to go around the fraternals and ask the same question - where there are older pastors less hands would go up, where the pastors are younger again I suspect it would be the majority.

None of this is to knock UCCF, but I suggest that this has been to the detriment of our outreach to other sections of British society and led to a homogenising of our constituency (white (with few exceptions), middle class and university educated) which would not have been the case 150 years ago.

What is Conservative Evangelicalism ?

Oliver Barclay 'Evangelicalism in Britain 1935 - 1995

'conservative evangelicals ' ... meaning those who maintain a doctrine of the reliability, sufficiency and final authority of the Bible and as a result maintain also the substitutionary character of the atonement ...'

I would also like to add that very often conservative evangelicals have held to a broadly calvinistic soteriology, that is the sovereignty of God in the salvation of Christians.

Tuesday, 12 April 2011

What is evangelicalism ?

The Bebbington Quadrilateral (in The advent of evangelicalism p48 - 49)

First, evangelicals 'held and practised the conviction that lives have to be transformed by the gospel, that people are not naturally Christians', a conviction that Bebbington terms 'Conversionism'. Then there was 'activism', which consisted 'primarily in spreading the gospel', that is, evangelism and missionary activity, but also involved doiing 'all sorts of humane works of charity'. Third, evangelicalism was marked by what Bebbington calls 'biblicism'. Evangelicals showed a deep'devotion to the Bible', which was a 'result of their belief that all spiritual truth is to be found in its pages'. Finally, evangelicals emphasised 'cruicentricism', that is, 'they ... placed at the centre of their theological scheme the doctrine of the cross - the atoning work of Jesus Christ in his death'.

The Proposal

That in the light of the Thesis, to seek the growth and vitality of conservative evangelicalism in Birmingham ...

i) an honesty about our position is required - we are very much on the margins in a post Christian environment. In contrast to popular models emanating from the US, we are not about to transform any neighbourhoods, and I want to posit there is not a single example of this in the UK currently, and this is even less likely to occur in Birmingham. Whilst I am unashamabley reformed, the anapbaptist writer Stuart Murray Williams is vastly more helpful to us (in terms of his analysis) than 99% of reformed writers from the US in this regard. In fact I would argue that there are hardly any writers from the US (including those in the most anti Christian cities, who can relate to whole neighbourhoods of 10s of thousands of people having maybe less than 100 Christians - most of whom would be elderly). It would help us in the UK, if US writers would be honest about the extent that their churches have benefitted from their 'Christianised environemnt' and the transfer in of Christians to their memberships. I also suspect some of the most anti Christian people they have seem come, are probably from a Christian background.

Additionally Post Colonialism

Post Welfare



Not only are we in a post Christian environment, as a group we are particularly ghettoised, which has much to do with the incubation of our social group in the narrow social groupings of British university life (which then continues in our churches), the 'tectonic' social relations in British inner cities (see the work of Tim Butler) and the social behaviour of the middle classes (The philosopher Zizek suggest there is something intrinsic in being middle class around excluding those who aren't). We (as a group) are not good at relating to different sorts of people. There are very few 'chameleons' (Please see the work of Sultana Choudhry) in our churches, these being those who are comfortable in different social and ethnic settings.



ii) a consideration of the task at hand over the next 30 years. for this I want to use Andrew Walls as a conversation partner.

iii) a refocussing on the task at hand with the accompanying allocation of resources, an essential part of which is the development of the necessary leaders for the task at hand

The Thesis

That the last 20 years of conservative evangelicalism in Birmingham, arose from a declining middle class Brethrenism, the conservative elements of the charismatic movement and an upper middle class anglicanism and has largely grown as a result of the expansion of higher education in the UK over the last 30 years.

These groups are now largely homegenous - white - middle class - socially conservative - university educated - not from birmingham

In the Birmingham of 2011, This group has a fairly unstable position

i) the cuts in higher education, increase in tuition fees, HE becomes more and more a preserve of elites

ii) the 'typical' social behaviours of the middle class in relation to Birm
a) 'the Birmingham sojourn' - they come to Birmingham to study and leave as soon as their studies are over

For those who stay ...
a) bureaucracy - they seek promotion by being prepared to travel the country / world ie they won't stay in Birm
b) education - they seek the best schools for their children, so will move areas to gain them ie to the suburbs / out of Birm
c) housing - they perceive a 'housing ladder', they buy a less expensive house in a less expensive area to get onto the 'ladder', when the family expands / they get promotion / the price is right, they move to up the ladder to another area ie to the suburbs / out of Brum
d) 'white flight' - this is true of both the white working and middle class, as more 'minorities' come to Birmingham, they leave ...

Therefore to focus on this group (in a context of seeking the growth and vitality of the church in Birmingham) is short termist, counterproductive and possibly in contravention of James Chapter 2